Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Divergent and Convergent Thinking in AI-Driven Creativity Ethical Implications for the Creative Design Industries

The rapid integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into creative industries is transforming established approaches to ideation, design production, and creative decision-making. While generative AI can produce diverse and novel outputs at unprecedented speed, questions remain regarding how AI influences the cognitive processes underlying creativity and whether machine-generated novelty constitutes meaningful creative performance. This study investigates divergent and convergent thinking in AI-driven creativity, focusing on professional graphic design practice and the ethical implications of human–AI collaboration.

Drawing on Guilford’s distinction between divergent and convergent thinking and subsequent developments in creativity research, the study conceptualises creativity as a dynamic process involving idea generation, evaluation, refinement, and contextual judgement. A mixed-methods experimental design compares professional graphic designers across three conditions: (1) without AI, (2) AI alone, and (3) human–AI collaboration. Divergent thinking is assessed through fluency, flexibility, originality, elaboration, pseudocreativity, and time efficiency. Convergent thinking is examined through accuracy, rule adherence, design quality, justification, and convergence speed. Quantitative performance measures are complemented by post-experimental questionnaires and semi-structured interviews examining participants’ perceptions of AI-assisted creativity, cognitive effort, confidence, creative freedom, and decision-making.

The study further examines the ethical implications of AI integration within creative practice, particularly authorship, intellectual property, originality, algorithmic bias, transparency, human agency, and the potential devaluation of professional creative labour. Rather than positioning AI solely as either an autonomous creator or a passive tool, the research investigates human–AI creativity as a collaborative process in which computational generation interacts with human interpretation, evaluation, contextual knowledge, and creative judgement.

By combining cognitive creativity theory with experimental and qualitative approaches, this research aims to provide empirical insight into how different levels of AI involvement shape divergent and convergent thinking in graphic design. The study contributes to emerging discussions on responsible AI-driven creativity by identifying opportunities and limitations of AI-assisted design and by emphasising the importance of preserving human agency and ethical accountability while harnessing AI’s potential to expand creative exploration and efficiency.

Attachment language: English File type: PDF document Presentation Poster
Updated: 30-10-2026 17:33 - Size: 1.67 MB
Attachment language: English File type: PDF document Presentation File
Updated: 30-10-2026 17:34 - Size: 2.59 MB
Speakers
Savvas Kyriakou

Back

ACM GreekCHI-CYCHI Symposium 2026


We are excited to invite you to the ACM GreekCHI-CYCHI Symposium 2026, held on November 6-7, 2026 jointly in Athens, Thessaloniki, Nicosia and Online.